Forum Review

I am looking for someone with experience in building or running a successful forum(s).

I need someone that can create detailed reviews of forums. Basically, its current performances, and how it can improve. Forum reviews should include the following:

Portal/Homepage:
Is there enough information about your site?
Is it easy to navigate to the forums?
How about the contrast and colors?
Logo/Banner:
Do you have a custom banner?
Does it match your forum's skin?
Is your banner professional?
Main Forum Page:
Is everything easy to read?
Are the rules clear?
Too many forums? Too few?
Forums:
Do most forums pertain to your forum's niche?
Is there an introductions board?
How about an off topic or chit chat board?
Community:
Are your boards well-moderated?
Do you have enough staff members? Too many?
Do your members stay active and enjoy themselves on your forum?
Advertising:
Does your forum have advertisements?
Are the advertisements large and overbearing?
Are they relevant to the theme of your forum?

These are some of the questions that would need to be included in the review. More would need to be included, and I would need someone that has the experience to help come up with ideas of what more a review should include for to be beneficial for a forum owner.

Work would be ongoing, as and when needed, and paid on a per review basis.